When a business stops being profitable: the lesson of the Virgin Islands
In 1917 Denmark sold the West Indies to the US for 25 million. Without slaves, sugar was not profitable. A lesson about obsolete business models.
4 min read

In this article
A historic sale that hides a business lesson
In the midst of World War I, Denmark made a decision that would change the map of the Caribbean: to sell its West Indies to the United States for 25 million dollars in gold. What we now know as the United States Virgin Islands (Saint Thomas, Saint John, Saint Croix and the nearby islets) ceased to belong to the Danish crown on March 31, 1917. The news, originally published in Genbeta, reveals an economic background that goes beyond geopolitics: a business model based on slavery and sugar had ceased to be profitable.
The economic system of the islands was based on sugar plantations worked by enslaved people. Although slavery was abolished in 1848, the business was already showing signs of exhaustion. According to the National Museum of Denmark, about 120,000 Africans were brought as slaves to the Caribbean by Danish ships. After abolition, planters had to pay for labor, the soils were exhausted and competition from beet sugar was taking its toll. The result: constant losses.

From profitability to strategic risk
The sale was not a whim. There were previous attempts, such as the one in 1902 for five million dollars, which failed in the Danish upper house. The context of the Great War added urgency: the United States feared that Germany could establish a base in the Caribbean. The secret negotiations between Copenhagen and the Woodrow Wilson administration culminated in a referendum in December 1916, where the Danes approved the sale. The agreement also included a declaration on Greenland, ensuring that the US would not oppose Danish interests on the island.
Beyond the historical anecdote, this episode offers several reflections applicable to the world of business and technology. Organizations, like empires, sometimes cling to business models that no longer work. Slavery was abominable, but furthermore, as a productive system, it became unsustainable. Distances aside, many SMEs today maintain processes, tools or even business lines that were profitable in the past but today only generate costs and risks.
What it means for an SME or an IT team
The history of the Virgin Islands reminds us of the importance of periodically reviewing the viability of our operating models. In the technological field, this translates into asking: are we still using oversized on-premise infrastructure because we have always done so? Are we maintaining a legacy application that consumes resources and no longer adds value? Or even a service provider that no longer adapts to our needs?
The Danish decision also illustrates the cost of inaction. The failed sale attempts in 1902 and the delay until 1917 meant years of losses. In an SME, maintaining an obsolete system or an unfavorable contract can erode margins for entire fiscal years. The key is to identify when an asset (physical or digital) has ceased to be profitable and act accordingly, whether by selling, migrating or transforming the model.
Furthermore, the external factor was decisive: competition from beet sugar and soil exhaustion. In the IT world, competition from new cloud providers, the emergence of more efficient technologies or regulatory changes can make what was cutting-edge yesterday obsolete. Environmental vigilance is essential.
Recommendations for the IT team
- Periodic audit of technological assets: review which systems, licenses and contracts still add value and which only generate costs. Just as Denmark evaluated its islands, your company must evaluate its stack.
- Don't wait for the crisis: the 1917 sale was accelerated by the fear of a German base. In your case, don't wait for a security breach or a system crash to renew infrastructure. A zero-day in VMware vCenter can be that trigger that forces you to act in a hurry.
- Consider migration as an opportunity: selling the islands allowed Denmark to get rid of a problem and the US to obtain a strategic position. Similarly, migrating to the cloud or renewing equipment can free up resources and improve competitiveness. If you are considering options, take a look at how VMware launches vSphere Express to recover SMEs.
- Document and learn from failed attempts: the failure of 1902 did not prevent the success of 1917. In IT, failed pilot projects should serve to refine the strategy, not to abandon continuous improvement.
History does not repeat itself, but sometimes it rhymes. Business models based on exploitation and lack of adaptation end up falling. Technology is a means, not an end, and as such it must serve profitability and sustainability.
At ForgeNEX we help SMEs and IT teams review their infrastructure and make decisions based on data, not inertia. If your company is still exploiting a "sugar" that no longer sells, perhaps it is time to consider a strategic sale of that technological asset.
Source: Genbeta. Analysis and adaptation: ForgeNEX.
Keep reading
- Hot router: practical solutions to prevent failures in your SME21 November 2026
- Sabadell fined 16.5 million for tying practices in mortgages21 November 2026
- Avanade acquires Plain Concepts: what it means for Spanish SMEs21 November 2026
- The Schwalbe case: when reputation collides with the archives20 November 2026
- Bathroom renovations: why the budget spirals and how to control it20 November 2026